What people are saying about Room

Room has been getting some amazing reviews, and who are we to argue?

"As a life-affirming fable of parent-child love, and an antidote to the prurience of so much crime fiction, it's a triumph, and deserves to be a hit." Daily Telegraph

"Emma Donoghue has written a heartbreaking, heart-racing unnerving novel." Waterstone's Books Quarterly

"With echoes of the Josef Fritzl case and touted as the most controversial novel of the summer, this book will...have you turning the pages until the wee hours" Grazia

"Part childhood adventure story, part adult thriller, Room is above all the most vivid, radiant and beautiful expression of maternal love I have ever read. Emma Donoghue has stared into the abyss, honoured her sources and returned with the literary equivalent of a great Madonna and Child. This book will break your heart." The Irish Times

"It takes a consummate writer to make us marvel at the mundane. Beckett's Waiting for Godot did it, of course. So did Aleksandr Solzhenitsyn's One Day in the Life of Ivan Denisovich, set in a 1950s Siberian labour camp. Emma Donoghue does it so spectacularly that we are taken by surprise when, in the middle of the novel, resourceful Ma's escape plans swing into action. The reader hurries on partly because Jack is so masterful a creation. Like John Boyne's Bruno in The Boy in the Striped Pyjamas, he knows more than he understands. And the dramatic irony heightens the poignancy of the tale as it progresses into the third section, which deals with life after abduction." The Irish Independent

"On one level a simple story about and extreme situation, it is also a novel in the tradition ofGulliver's Travels, with Jack's perspective allowing Donoghue to hold the adult world up to an unfamiliar type of scrutiny" The Sunday Times

"The story is told, with unsurpassed panache...Room will certainly be much garlanded, and it will deserve every prize it gets. Fantastic - but deeply, deeply disturbing." AN Wilson - Readers Digest

"Room is likely to attract comparisons with Alice Sebold's The Lovely Bones and it deserves equal success...In the hands of a lesser author, Room could have felt both exploitative and sensationalist thanks to its subject matter. Instead, it makes the reader think about the importance of freedom and its costs. Above all though, it is a novel about the love between a mother and her child. Which is why, despite its darkest of settings, Room is an affecting and uplifting read." Evening Standard

"An absolute gem of a book! By turns poignant, emotional and yet with a fundamental humanity that good things can come out of the worst experiences...Donoghue's masterly handling of Jack's character was honest and believable throughout...I sincerely hope that this book makes the shortlist for its brave individuality and also its very sensitive handling of events that happen in real life. A wonderful novel." Jackie, Waterstones Cheltenham

'I've never read a more heart-burstingly, gut wrenchingly compassionate novel . . . As for sweet, bright, funny Jack, I wanted to scoop him up out of the novel and never let him go. In him,.Donoghue has created 21st-century fiction's most uniquely loveable voice. She deserves to win this year's Man Booker Prize.' Daily Mail

'Room is a fascinating, engagingly written account of a child-parent relationship. Wider implications are that human beings need room of their own to remain true to themselves.'
Methodist Recorder

'extraordinary power of Donoghue;s utterly gripping story which, although not essentially just hers, has never been told in such a way before.' Mirror Book of the Week ****

'In filling this book with things that are both truly horrific and rather lovely, Emma Donoghue has achieved a work that is deeply unsettling on every level. It is a strange paradox that a book about imprisonment and torture should have become an arean for discussing the proper care and love of children. I think I am glad to have read it.' Financial Times

'Room manages to tell a compelling story without disturbing this delicate - and in today's prurient televised times - almost impossible balance.' Times Literary Supplement

'What saves this beautifully nuanced book from being in any way a voyeuristic reaction to true crime is less the descriptions of captivity than the inevitably changing nature of the child / parent relationship, which Donoghue explores here so minutely, recognizably and exultantly.' Sunday Telegraph

'Not many writers, though, would have had the courage, or the ability, to visit this particular place and produce such a startlingly original and moving piece of work . . . it is a testament to Donoghue's skill how quickly that voice becomes acceptable, then endearing and finally utterly compelling, as compelling as the murdered young girl who narrated Alice Sebold's The Lovely bones. In the best novels, every word matters. And in the very best, every word not only matters, it helps transform how we see the world around us. Elisabeth Fritzl's case altered for many of us our view of the world. Donoghue's book has done exactly the same thing. It is a tremendous achievement.' Scotsman

'Although Room is entirely told from Jack's viewpoint, we learn much about Ma. As in Cormac McCarthy's The Road, we see how the love of a child in adversity can make a hero of an ordinary person. . . . [an] intense and absorbing novel . . . So closely has Emma Donoghue made us identify with her characters that, through Jack's eyes, we can see our own world made new.' Literary Review

'Donoghue focuses on Jack's transition and journey with aplomb.' Catholic Herald

We'd love to know what you thought of Room, so tell us by leaving a comment below or byemailing us with your reviews.

annecater
annecater posted a comment
Friday 13th Aug 2010 02:03
Fantastic book, I am left stunned! My Waterstone's and Amazon review here:
Emma Donoghue's Room has been long-listed for the 2010 Booker Prize and if it doesnt get on the short-list then go on to win I will be completely amazed. I think I can safely say that is the best book that I have read for a very long time, in fact, it's possibly the best book that I have ever read.

The story opens on Jack' fifth birthday - a birthday that he will celebrate in Room with his Ma. Jack has always lived in Room, he has never been outside of this 11 foot by 11 foot room, in fact Jack believes that nowhere else exists. His friends include Table, Door, Wardrobe and Plant, he watches Dora on TV, he sees other people, flowers, trees, roads and the sea on TV programmes, but he believes that they are 'only in TV'.

The only other thing that ever enters Room is 'Old Nick' - the man who brings them clothes and food and if they are lucky a 'sunday treat'. Jack hides in Wardrobe when Old Nick appears, counting the bed squeaks until he leaves again and Jack can join Ma in her bed.

Emma Donoghue has created a wonderfully endearing character in Jack, his narrative is atmospheric, imaginative yet very credible. Jack's vocabulary is a little strange and often stilted yet so descriptive, he sees everything in such a limited way yet the story of how Ma and Jack came to be in Room soon unfolds. As Jack is so young and had no experience of the wider world, he sees nothing wrong in the way that they live, yet the reader sees between the lines and the full horror of their experiences are soon understood as you continue to read.

It is when Ma decides to 'unlie' about Room and their situation that the pace quickens, as Jack beings to slowly realise that Room is not the entire universe and they gradually consider ways to escape his whole world changes, so many questions, so many 'unlies' to consider.

This book evokes some very strong feelings, I went through a realm of emotions from shock and horror to sadness and sorrow - it is a story of the human race and of innocence and love.

There is a quote from Audrey Niffenegger on the front of the book, she says "..... when it's over you look up: the world looks the same but you are somehow different and that feeling lingers for days."

I have no doubt that this story will stay with me for a very long time, there are many things to consider. This is totally unique, unlike any novel that I have read before and I doubt I will read anything that is so affecting again.
 
Mike Grady
Mike Grady posted a comment
Monday 16th Aug 2010 12:13
Hi Anne, thanks for your review! Glad you loved it as much as we do.
 
eve
eve posted a comment
Wednesday 8th Sep 2010 11:18
Room is the first selection for my newly minted book club. It was chosen hastily over a quick lunch with the co-founder of the club. I knew little of the novel: long listed; about a kidnap; by successful Irish author. My assumption was that the kidnap had occurred as a result of a political situation - I was thinking of the French journalist captured in south America - and so when I began reading I became fearful that other members of the club would be horrified by the choice. By the time I had finished (which would have been in one sitting had not the need to go to work interrupted me) my fear had evaporated. This is a wonderful book, the subject is sensitively and cleverly handled by an accomplished author. It's a spot on choice for a good discussion at our first book club meeting.
 
Mike Grady
Mike Grady replied
Thursday 9th Sep 2010 11:29
Hi Eve, thanks for letting us know about your reading group, and we're so glad you liked the book. We really appreciate your feedback.

Email us at picadorblog@macmillan.co.uk, we'd love to know more about your reading group!

Mike.
 
eve
eve posted a comment
Wednesday 20th Oct 2010 07:49
Well, Room was well received by the book club members. The book scored 8/10 but that might be a little skewed as it was our first meeting. Next up is East of the Mountains by David Guterson. I've read this novel before and enjoyed it as well as Guterson's Snow Falling on Cedars. I love Guterson's ability to paint a landscape, in ways it reminds me of Hardy and his technique of developing the setting as a character. I love too the author's ability to convey the protagonist's love for his deceased wife: "he remembered her, too, slicing carrots with a paring knife, the ball of her thumb, a stop." An observation of a domestic chore becomes poetic in recollection.
 
PW
PW posted a comment
Thursday 20th Jan 2011 12:29
Brilliant read. Read it in 2 nights - couldn't put it down, totally gripping
 
Bibliofi
Bibliofi posted a comment
Sunday 6th Feb 2011 02:19
I was fortunate to receive a free copy of this book in return for a review, so thank you to Picador & to Alison B McN!
I have been wondering how I could review it without giving away the plot, but I needn't have worried because as soon as I put the book down, the review just tumbled out....with no spoilers! Here it is:
Don't be afraid, as I was, to read this book; it's beautiful.
Yes, it is dark and shocking and upsetting, but the story is redeemed by Jack's irrepressable and accepting approach to his universe as he knows it.
This is the story of an incredibly brave woman who - in the meanest of circumstances - has managed to produce an incredibly intelligent, thoughtful and well-educated child. And the depth of their mutual, exclusive love is breath-taking.
The premise of a five year old narrator is so refreshingly original and his unusual experiences have so coloured his thought processes, that you are intrigued by what his reactions might be as he begins to discover that the world is not just another piece of Room.
By turns horrifying, heart-stopping, hilarious, poignant, overwhelming, frustrating and fascinating; there is great hope in this novel. It gives you a fresh pair of eyes to turn on the world and insight into the workings of our minds, both as adults and as children.
Read it - you really won't regret it.
 
ees
ees posted a comment
Thursday 17th Feb 2011 11:31
Room is a book I never intended to read. My reason for this was knowing where the idea for the book originated. I was quite wrong to judge it unread.

Although disturbing as the first part is, the story is so beautifully written and endearingly entertaining that it turned out to be a wonderful and thought provoking read.
 
Chatty Chicks
Chatty Chicks posted a comment
Wednesday 6th Apr 2011 04:26
Our book club also received a free copy in return for a review. We were happy to do this as it was a book we all wanted to read and we even squeezed in an extra meeting(with a curry)to fit it in to our reading schedule. What a great deal of thought and discussion it provoked. Some found it a stilted and difficult read at first but all agreed that it turned into a fast paced page turner by the time of the escape. We all thought Ma a wonderful, courageous woman, only really a child herself when imprisoned. The outside world proves to be as challenging and difficult to adapt to as the imprisoned one. Behind the tale of imprisonment,brutality and fear is a wonderful story of hope, sacrifice and trust.Child/parent relationships are explored and there are some touching scenes between Jack and Steppa. Difficult to pick up (because of the subject)but impossible to put down. You will not regret reading it.
 

You need to be logged in to comment.